Today I have tried my first Cottage Trash Plate and I would rate 8.5/10. If we donโt mention about the presentation of the food (accurate to the name), Cottage Trash Plate was an absolute joy. And ladies who are servers were very helpful, chill and pretty. I saved this place to my secret getaways.
Overview
Nestled in the charming town of Mendon, New York, the Cottage Hotel Of Mendon offers a delightful dining experience that combines comfort, taste, and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Located at 1390 Pittsford Mendon Rd, this cozy establishment is a perfect spot for those seeking a relaxed yet high-quality meal. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, this diner stands out as a local favorite with its impressive menu and friendly service.
One of the standout features of the Cottage Hotel Of Mendon is its diverse menu that caters to a wide range of tastes. From hearty breakfast options like fluffy pancakes and scrambled eggs to lunch and dinner selections such as tender steaks and flavorful seafood, there's something for everyone. The restaurant takes pride in sourcing fresh, locally grown ingredients, ensuring each dish is as tasty as it is satisfying. During a recent visit, I was particularly impressed by the homemade pies-rich, buttery, and packed with flavor, theyโre a must-try for anyone with a sweet tooth.
The atmosphere of the restaurant is one of the first things you'll notice upon entering. The interior is both welcoming and homely, with rustic decor that creates a comfortable environment for diners to relax and enjoy their meals. The friendly staff adds to the overall charm, always ready with a smile and helpful recommendations. Itโs clear that they care deeply about making your dining experience enjoyable.
For those looking for a special evening out, the Cottage Hotel Of Mendon also offers a great selection of drinks. Their bar area is stocked with a variety of local wines and craft beers, making it easy to pair your meal with the perfect beverage. The casual yet refined environment makes it a great place for family gatherings, casual dates, or even business lunches.
The Cottage Hotel Of Mendon is also known for its consistent, top-tier service. From the moment you walk in, you're treated like family. The staff goes above and beyond to ensure that each guest has a memorable experience, which is why many people return again and again. In fact, several regulars mentioned that the staff knows them by name, making the place feel like a second home.
What makes this restaurant particularly special is the personal touch it offers. The owner, who is often present during peak hours, is passionate about the food and the local community. The Cottage Hotel has a longstanding history of serving delicious meals and providing excellent service, which has earned it a loyal following over the years.
In terms of location, the Cottage Hotel Of Mendon is easily accessible, located just a short drive from the bustling town center. Whether you're a local or just passing through, the restaurantโs central location makes it a convenient stop for anyone in the area. Plus, with plenty of parking available, getting in and out is a breeze.
As far as pricing goes, the Cottage Hotel offers good value for the quality of food and service provided. Itโs not the cheapest option in town, but the portions are generous, and the overall dining experience is well worth the cost. Their specials, which change regularly, provide even more variety and value, ensuring that thereโs always something new to try.
Many online reviews praise the Cottage Hotel Of Mendon for its consistency in both food and service. Repeat visitors often highlight their experiences with specific menu items, such as the famous meatloaf or the creamy mashed potatoes, which keep them coming back. Itโs these kinds of details that make the Cottage Hotel not just another diner but a beloved spot where people can always expect a satisfying meal and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
For anyone looking to explore what Mendon has to offer, a visit to the Cottage Hotel Of Mendon is highly recommended. Whether you're stopping by for a casual meal or a special celebration, this local gem is sure to provide a memorable dining experience.
Good to know
From the business
โ Identifies as women-ownedService options
โ Outdoor seating โ Kerbside pickup โ Takeaway โ Dine-in โ DeliveryHighlights
โ Fast service โ Great beer selection โ Great cocktails โ Great wine list โ Live music โ Serves local specialty โ SportPopular for
โ Lunch โ Dinner โ Solo diningAccessibility
โ Wheelchair-accessible car park โ Wheelchair-accessible toiletOfferings
โ Alcohol โ Beer โ Cocktails โ Coffee โ Comfort food โ Happy-hour drinks โ Happy-hour food โ Late-night food โ Quick bite โ Small plates โ Spirits โ Vegan options โ Vegetarian options โ WineDining options
โ Lunch โ Dinner โ Dessert โ Seating โ Table serviceAmenities
โ Bar on site โ Toilet โ Wi-Fi โ Wi-FiAtmosphere
โ Casual โ Cosy โ Historic โ TrendyCrowd
โ Family friendly โ Groups โ LGBTQ+ friendly โ Tourists โ Transgender safe spacePlanning
โ Accepts reservationsPayments
โ Credit cards โ Debit cards โ NFC mobile payments โ Credit cardsChildren
โ Good for kids โ High chairs โ Kids' menuParking
โ Free of charge street parking โ ParkingPets
โ Dogs allowed outsidePhotos
Location
Reviews
Full house upon arrival and we were told the kitchen was backed up, but they could seat us and serve drinks. Once we ordered, the food came out fast and was delicious! Grilled peach arugula salad with salmon was TASTY! $21. Genny Kolsch $5 a pint. Bud light $3.50 to me that's fantastic! Better Days band was great! Favorite songs from 70's. The downside was it was a tad warm inside on an 86ยฐ day, but with my handheld fan I was very comfortable. And yes, there was a wait to order but not a problem since we were kept informed. Would definitely return.
On the smaller side. The employees are super friendly and caring! Great music! We saw Mr. Heartache there. Add the smiles, food and libations, and you've got the total package for a great night out.
Got into town around 10:30pm on a Sunday in late July. Unfamiliar with the area, I called to find most kitchens closed. The young woman on the phone at Cottage, honestly let me know the kitchen was closed except fried apps would be available. I walked in and the bartender, Michaela, greeted me with such warm hospitality. I got the food that I wanted with some suggestions from her. I had a really good time, great conversation with Michaela, felt welcomed and left full.
The Cottage is a terrific casual spot to stop for lunch or dinner & live music. Great atmosphere, wonderful people, and always fun. Pro tip - get the Cincinnati chili with onions & cheese!
I wish I had taken pics because the burger was very impressive. Next time Iโm in the mood for a burger, I might just drive all the way out to Mendon.
The waitresses are all so friendly and helpful. Every one of them is happy to help; I'm not sure they have assigned tables. Dan makes a PERFECT lemon drop martini and their food is much better than you'd expect for a tiny local bar. Their chef comes up with some wonderful dishes. I love their fish fry!